MovieChat Forums > Shameless (2011) Discussion > Why does this series receive so much pra...

Why does this series receive so much praise?


I've only just finished the 7th episode of season 2 and while I find the series mildly entertaining (as far as brainless comedies go), word of mouth had me expecting far more.

I've been a huge William H. Macy fan since I was a teenager and first saw him in the likes of Fargo and all those PT Anderson movies. So, right off the bat, I was intrigued about him staring in a TV series. I figured it had to be great. And, on top of that, I've repeatedly heard people and critics rave about the series for years, speaking about how real it is and how it delves deeply and intelligently into so many relatable and taboo issues (with a hefty dose of comedy thrown into the mix). I was expecting an R-rated Roseanne or something. A dramedy on par (or perhaps surpassing) the likes of Freaks and Geeks, The Wonder Years, or Six Feet Under. And what do I find but silly caricatures, one absurd and wacky situation after another, hacky dialogue, WB-level melodrama, and a slew of gratuitous sex, nudity, and "shocking" scenes that appear to be there for the sole purpose of shocking (as opposed to actually serving the story in any meaningful way).

Don't get me wrong, it's watchable. But why on earth does this receive so much praise? The way people speak, I figured I was walking into something far better and deeper than this. As far as I can tell, it's more on par with Weeds, Californication, Sex and The City, Hung, or Orange Is The New Black than any other of those intelligently written shows I've mentioned. Does it get drastically better in later seasons or something? Because, thus far, it seems extremely mediocre and goofy (it's almost cartoonish half the time).

reply

you don't know why???? it makes whites look bad.

reply

Just HAD to bring race into the conversation didn’t you.

reply

What else can a 1-trick pony do?

reply

True.

reply

I don’t think of white trash as being white, and I’m not alone.

reply

What do you mean?

reply

Sorry for the late reply. White is much more than a color. It's also a culture. White trash have no self-respect. They have distanced themselves from being white.

reply

What is white culture? I'm white, my family comes from France, we don't have much in common with the white people across the street who come from Germany.

reply

THAT is the dumbest most racist thing I have head ---- You mean like African Americans who can't find Africa on a map???

reply

THAT is the dumbest most racist thing I have heard ---- You mean like African Americans who can't find Africa on a map???

reply

First I want to say the acting is wonderful. Everyone understands their role (even day players) and plays it accordingly.

I am on season 5 episode 5, and honestly I am barely paying attention at this point cause its the same shenanigans.

So, yeah, I agree, c'mon the praise that this show got is laughable. And 10 seasons?, hahahahahahah.

You said it best, WB-level melodrama. The fact that fans hoped that Jimmy/Steve and Fiona got back together.
Two Losers on two different level of loserdom. (eye roll)

And I don't get how Debbie in early episodes is just so naïve to sex and all that at 14??????
Older sister, and older brothers in a "keep it real" household and she learned nothing.
This part of the show is really irking me.

I feel they have to push the drug addict parents on us causese honestly the kids are not right in the head.
Non of them. I wouldn't put past that all of them eat paint chips.

And I don't care how often we see them in towels and wet hair. No one will ever convince me that any of these kids bathe.

reply